U1 News
  • Home
  • World
  • U.S.
  • Business
  • Technology
  • Science
  • Entertainment
  • Sport
  • Health
Global News

Israel targets Hezbollah commander in Beirut strike after deadly Golan Heights attack

July 30, 2024

Taylor Swift speaks out after Southport mass stabbing at dance class

July 30, 2024

3 girls killed in stabbing at Taylor Swift-themed UK dance class. 7 people still critically wounded

July 30, 2024
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Trending
  • FDA approves first at-home HPV test to screen for cervical cancer
  • Brain stimulation technology improves Parkinson’s treatment for music conductor
  • Left-handedness linked to autism, schizophrenia in major neurological study
  • Heart health unexpectedly affected by shingles vaccine
  • Doctors remove spinal cancer through eye socket in revolutionary surgery
  • Laundry done at home by healthcare workers may spread superbugs, says new study
  • Longevity and organ function predicted in new ‘body clock’ tool
  • ‘Magic mushrooms’ may offer major relief for Parkinson’s patients, study shows
Saturday, May 10
U1 News
  • Home
  • World

    Israel targets Hezbollah commander in Beirut strike after deadly Golan Heights attack

    July 30, 2024

    Taylor Swift speaks out after Southport mass stabbing at dance class

    July 30, 2024

    3 girls killed in stabbing at Taylor Swift-themed UK dance class. 7 people still critically wounded

    July 30, 2024

    Kerala, India, hit by landslides, killing at least 99

    July 30, 2024

    Taylor Swift ‘in shock’ after horrific UK stabbing, as police say 3rd child dies

    July 30, 2024
  • U.S.

    Biden criticises ‘extreme’ Supreme Court in push for reform

    July 30, 2024

    FBI details shooter’s search history before Trump assassination attempt

    July 30, 2024

    Reps. Mike Kelly, Jason Crow to lead task force on Trump rally shooting

    July 29, 2024

    Biden to call for major Supreme Court reforms, including term limits, at Civil Rights Act event Monday

    July 29, 2024

    Sonya Massey’s death revives pain for Breonna Taylor, Floyd activists

    July 29, 2024
  • Business

    AMD stock jumps on earnings beat driven by AI chip sales

    July 30, 2024

    Amazon is responsible for dangerous products sold on its site, federal agency rules

    July 30, 2024

    Microsoft investigating new outages of services after global CrowdStrike chaos

    July 30, 2024

    S&P 500, Nasdaq Tumble as Chip Stocks Slide Ahead of Big Tech Earnings

    July 30, 2024

    American consumers feeling more confident in July as expectations of future improve

    July 30, 2024
  • Technology

    Apple says Safari protects your privacy. We fact checked those claims.

    July 30, 2024

    GameStop Dunks On Xbox 360 Store Closing And Gets Savaged

    July 30, 2024

    Logitech has an idea for a “forever mouse” that requires a subscription

    July 30, 2024

    Friend: a new digital companion for the AI age

    July 30, 2024

    London Sports Mod Community Devolves Into War

    July 30, 2024
  • Science

    NASA’s Lunar Gateway has a big visiting vehicles problem

    August 1, 2024

    Boeing’s Cursed ISS Mission May Finally Make It Back to Earth

    July 30, 2024

    Should you floss before or after you brush your teeth?

    July 30, 2024

    Ancient swimming sea bug ‘taco’ had mandibles, new fossils show

    July 30, 2024

    NASA’s DART asteroid impact mission revealed ages of twin space rock targets (images)

    July 30, 2024
  • Entertainment

    Richard Gadd Backs Netflix to Get ‘Baby Reindeer’ Lawsuit Dismissed

    July 30, 2024

    Batman: Caped Crusader review: a pulpy throwback to DC’s Golden Age

    July 30, 2024

    Channing Tatum Praises Ryan Reynolds For Taking Gamble On Gambit

    July 30, 2024

    ‘Star Wars Outlaws’ somehow made me fall in love with Star Wars again

    July 30, 2024

    Great Scott and O’Brien’s Pub find new life in Allston

    July 30, 2024
  • Sport

    How Snoop Dogg became a fixture of the Paris Olympics

    July 30, 2024

    Team USA’s Coco Gauff exits Olympics singles tournament with a third-round loss : NPR

    July 30, 2024

    French police investigating abuse targeting Olympic opening ceremony DJ over ‘Last Supper’ scene

    July 30, 2024

    French DJ Takes Legal Action

    July 30, 2024

    Why BYU’s Jimmer Fredette is at the 2024 Paris Olympics

    July 30, 2024
  • Health

    FDA approves first at-home HPV test to screen for cervical cancer

    May 10, 2025

    Brain stimulation technology improves Parkinson’s treatment for music conductor

    May 10, 2025

    Left-handedness linked to autism, schizophrenia in major neurological study

    May 10, 2025

    Heart health unexpectedly affected by shingles vaccine

    May 9, 2025

    Doctors remove spinal cancer through eye socket in revolutionary surgery

    May 9, 2025
U1 News
Home»Science»Researchers discover a new form of scientific fraud: Uncovering ‘sneaked references’
Science

Researchers discover a new form of scientific fraud: Uncovering ‘sneaked references’

u1news-staffBy u1news-staffJuly 11, 2024No Comments6 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Research 1.jpg
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

It is a classic but misleading image that researchers work alone, isolated from the world and the scientific community at large: in reality, research is based on continuous interaction within the scientific community, first to understand the work of others and then to share our own findings.

Reading and writing published articles Academic Journals Writing research papers and presenting at conferences is an important part of being a researcher. When researchers write academic papers, they need to cite the work of their colleagues to provide context, detail sources of inspiration, and explain differences in approach or results. Positive citations by other researchers are an important indicator of the visibility of a researcher’s own work.

But what happens when this citation system is manipulated? Journal of Information Science and Technologyarticle Research by our academic research team, which includes information scientists, computer scientists, and mathematicians, has uncovered a clever way to artificially inflate citation counts through metadata manipulation: “stealth hidden references.”

Hidden operations

People are becoming more aware Scientific Publications How it works, including potential flaws. In the last year alone 10,000 scientific papers retractedThe problems with citation games and the damage they cause to the scientific community (including the undermining of credibility) are well documented.

Citations of scientific articles follow a standardized referencing system: each reference explicitly states at least the title, author, year of publication, journal or conference name, and page number of the cited publication. These details are stored as metadata and are not directly visible in the article text, but are assigned to a Digital Object Identifier (DOI), a unique identifier for each scientific publication.

References in scientific publications allow authors to justify methodological choices and present the results of previous studies, emphasizing the iterative and collaborative nature of science.

However, by chance, we discovered that some bad actors, while submitting their papers to scientific databases, add additional references that do not appear in the text but are present in the paper’s metadata. The result? A sudden increase in the number of citations for certain researchers and journals, even though these references are not cited by the authors in their papers.

Accidental discovery

The study was conducted by Professor Guillaume Cabanac of the University of Toulouse. Pub PierIn a post on PewDiePie, a website dedicated to post-publication peer review, where scientists discuss and analyze publications, he detailed how he noticed the discrepancy: the Hindawi article, which he suspected was fraudulent because it contained awkward wording, had received far more citations than it had downloaded, which is highly unusual.

This post caught the attention of several detectives, who are now JASIST article. We used scientific search engines to look for papers that cited our first paper. We found nothing in Google Scholar, but we found references in Crossref and Dimensions. What’s the difference? Google Scholar tends to rely primarily on the body of the paper to extract references that appear in the references section, while Crossref and Dimensions use metadata provided by the publisher.

A new type of fraud

To understand the extent of the manipulation, we looked at three scientific journals published by Technoscience Academy, the publisher of the paper containing the questionable citations.

Our study consists of three steps:

  1. We have listed references that are explicitly present in the HTML or PDF version of the article.
  2. We compared these lists with the metadata recorded by Crossref and discovered additional references that were added to the metadata but not shown in the article.
  3. Further inconsistencies were found when we looked at Dimensions, a bibliographic platform that uses Crossref as a metadata source.

In journals published by Technoscience Academy, at least 9% of the recorded references were “hidden references”. These additional references were only included in the metadata, distorting the citation counts and giving an unfair advantage to certain authors. Some legitimate references were also missing and not present in the metadata.

Moreover, our analysis of the smuggled citations shows that some researchers have benefited significantly: for example, one researcher affiliated with the Technoscience Academy benefited from over 3,000 additional fraudulent citations, while several journals from the same publisher also benefited from hundreds of additional smuggled citations.

We posted the results of our study because we wanted external validation of our results. As a preprintCrossref notified both Crossref and Dimensions of our findings and provided links to the pre-printed survey. Dimensions acknowledged the fraudulent citations and confirmed that their database reflects Crossref’s data. Crossref confirmed Additional references Retraction Watch They also stressed that this was the first time they had been notified of such a problem with the database, and the publisher has taken steps to correct the problem based on Crossref’s investigation.

Impact and potential solutions

Why is this finding important? Citation counts heavily influence research funding, academic promotion, and institutional rankings. Manipulating citations could lead to unjust decisions based on faulty data. More concerning, the finding raises questions about the integrity of scientific impact measurement systems, which have been pointed out by researchers for years. These systems can be manipulated to promote unhealthy competition among researchers, tempting them to take shortcuts to publish faster or earn more citations.

To combat this practice, we propose several measures.

  • Rigorous validation of metadata by publishers and agencies such as Crossref.
  • Independent audits to ensure data reliability.
  • Increased transparency in managing references and citations.

This study is, to our knowledge, the first to report on the manipulation of metadata. We also discuss the impact this has on the evaluation of researchers. This study reiterates that an over-reliance on metrics to evaluate researchers, their research, and their impact is inherently flawed and potentially erroneous.

Such over-reliance can lead to making hypotheses after the results are known, Harkingsplitting one dataset into multiple papers (salami slicing), data manipulation, plagiarism. It also prevents transparency, which is key to getting more research done. Strong and Efficient Research: Problematic QuoteMetadata The sneakily hidden reference was apparently fixed, so the fix may have been fixed. This is common in scientific corrections.it was too late.

Provided by
conversation


This article is reprinted from conversation Published under a Creative Commons license. Original Article.conversation

Quote: Researchers Uncover New Form of Scientific Fraud: “Sneaky Hidden References” Uncovered (July 10, 2024) Retrieved July 10, 2024 from https://phys.org/news/2024-07-scientific-fraud-uncovering.html

This document is subject to copyright. It may not be reproduced without written permission, except for fair dealing for the purposes of personal study or research. The content is provided for informational purposes only.

discover form fraud material Nanotechnology Physics Physics News references Researchers Science Science News scientific sneaked Technology Technology News Uncovering
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
u1news-staff
u1news-staff
  • Website

Related Posts

Brain stimulation technology improves Parkinson’s treatment for music conductor

May 10, 2025

Alarming fungus could invade parts of the US, researchers warn

May 6, 2025

Some paper receipts pose health risks due to Bisphenol S, researchers warn

April 24, 2025

Dementia risk could decrease with technology use, study suggests

April 17, 2025
Add A Comment

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Latest Posts

FDA approves first at-home HPV test to screen for cervical cancer

May 10, 2025

Brain stimulation technology improves Parkinson’s treatment for music conductor

May 10, 2025

Left-handedness linked to autism, schizophrenia in major neurological study

May 10, 2025

Heart health unexpectedly affected by shingles vaccine

May 9, 2025
Unites States

Biden criticises ‘extreme’ Supreme Court in push for reform

July 30, 2024

FBI details shooter’s search history before Trump assassination attempt

July 30, 2024

Reps. Mike Kelly, Jason Crow to lead task force on Trump rally shooting

July 29, 2024

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest sports news from SportsSite about soccer, football and tennis.

Copyright ©️ All rights reserved. | U1 News
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Disclaimer

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.